About Master Jewelers


The passion to create beauty with precious gems and metals thrills us, as well as our clients. You are an individual with a unique style, and we believe your jewelry should reflect the creativity within. Whether it’s an engagement ring, a wedding ring, a Valentine’s Day gift, or another special moment, Master Jewelers partners with you to create and design the jewelry that will last a lifetime. Your jewelry is a representation of a moment, frozen in time: This is what it means to fall in love.

Since 1988, Master Jewelers has provided award-winning custom designs. We have partnered with other respected designers from around the world to provide you with one-of-a-kind, exclusive jewelry collections. Our MasterTech Services offer a range of features such as repairs, cleaning, and appraisals.

Please visit our jewelry showroom to discover a world of beauty, design, and love.



One of the highest certifications is to be a JA Certified Master Bench Jeweler – a Master Jeweler. This certification requires four levels of testing which includes a Master Jeweler exam that requires the candidate to create three highly-complex jewelry pieces. These take 40 hours to complete and accompany an extensive written text demonstrating gem treatments, safety issues, and technical knowledge.



Business and ethics are not separate. This is why we are committed to sourcing Conflict Free diamonds. Putting people before profits IS good business.

High-quality diamonds should not come at great social and environmental cost. We are also committed to the adoption of Fair Trade, helping the workers and their families create a better life for themselves. We source diamonds from mines that adhere to strict labor, trade, and environmental standards.


Master Jewelers are made up of people who are “masters” in their own right. It is because of them, we have been able to serve our clients with passion and artistry.

President and Master Craftsman

Michael Neylon – President and Master Craftsman

Born and raised on the Southside of Indianapolis, Mike attended Roncalli High School.  He planned to attend Ball State University, but happened upon the jewelry industry by chance and instantly fell in love.  He began a Master Craftsman apprenticeship with DDI in 1984, during which he won many awards in custom design, model-making, and stone setting.  Shortly thereafter he began a wholesale business performing repairs and custom work for many of the jewelers in Central Indiana.  He has been serving the retail jewelry customers of central Indiana since 1990 and still enjoys working on the bench, transforming client’s jewelry dreams into reality.  In his spare time, Mike enjoys anything to do with racing, the Colts, or the Pacers, and spending time down on his property outside of Bloomington.



Jewelry Expert

Christine G. – Jewelry Expert

With a degree in creative writing from Ball State, not only does Christine add an extra dimension to our social media and marketing, but she also enjoys conjuring up creative ways for clients to express their emotions and personalities in custom jewelry. Outside of work, Christine enjoys hunting for discarded treasures, crafting, and spending time with her family.





Millissa K. – Jewelry Expert and Office Manager


Millissa recently made a return to her passion in the jewelry industry after owning and operating two successful businesses. Millissa brings a vast knowledge of both jewelry and business to our team. Utilizing both her degree in Business Management from Vincennes University and her Diamond and Pearl Certifications from GIA. With over 15 years in jewelry experience, Millissa combines her love of family, faith, and jewelry into creating, restoring, and designing family heirlooms meant to carry on memories from the past to the generations of the future.





Mark H.– Craftsman

In addition to performing jewelry repairs, Mark provides the logistics for our shop, making sure that each and every item is exactly right.  His skill and attention to detail allow Mark to always hit the mark in every job he completes.  Outside of work, Mark also enjoys music, acting as a DJ for events and working sound for several local bands.